News
Comparison of Screw, Centrifugal, and Reciprocating Piston Compressors
• Screw compressor
Screw compressors are also known as screw-type compressors. As early as the 1950s, oil‑injected screw compressors were already being used in refrigeration systems. Thanks to their simple design, few wear parts, ability to operate under large pressure differentials or pressure ratios, low discharge temperatures, insensitivity to refrigerants containing substantial amounts of lubricating oil (often referred to as “wet operation”), and excellent capacity‑control characteristics, they quickly supplanted reciprocating compressors in the high‑capacity range and have continued to expand into the medium‑capacity segment. They are now widely employed in refrigeration systems for freezing, cold storage, air conditioning, and chemical processes.
Screw‑type heat pumps, with the screw compressor as their core component, have been employed in heating and air-conditioning applications since the early 1970s. They come in various configurations, including air‑source, water‑source, heat‑recovery, and ice‑storage types. In the industrial sector, screw‑type heat pumps are also utilized for waste‑heat recovery to enhance energy efficiency.
• Centrifugal compressor
A centrifugal compressor is a rotary‑blade compressor, also known as a turbocompressor. In such a compressor, the high‑speed rotating impeller imparts centrifugal force to the gas, while the diffuser passage further increases the gas pressure through deceleration and expansion.
In its early days, this type of compressor was suitable only for low- and medium-pressure, high‑flow applications, and thus received little attention. With the development of the chemical industry and the construction of large chemical plants and refineries, centrifugal compressors became indispensable equipment for compressing and transporting various gases in chemical production, assuming an extremely important role. Advances in gas dynamics have continuously improved the efficiency of centrifugal compressors, while breakthroughs in key technologies—such as high‑pressure sealing, precision machining of small‑flow, narrow‑impeller designs, and multi‑oil‑wedge bearings—have resolved a series of challenges associated with expanding centrifugal compressors into higher pressure ranges and broader flow regimes. As a result, the application scope of centrifugal compressors has been greatly broadened, enabling them to replace reciprocating compressors in many situations and significantly extending their range of use.
• Reciprocating piston compressor
It is the earliest type of compressor to be developed; in 1500 BC, China invented the wooden bellows, which served as a prototype for the reciprocating piston compressor. At the end of the 18th century, Britain built the first industrial reciprocating piston air compressor. Beginning in the 1930s, labyrinth compressors emerged, followed by various oil-free lubricated compressors and diaphragm compressors. The advent of rotary‑type designs in the 1950s significantly reduced the size of large reciprocating piston compressors and enabled single units to serve multiple purposes.
Reciprocating compressors have a long history of use and remain the most widely employed type of compressor in China today. They offer a broad pressure range, can accommodate a wide spectrum of power ratings, and boast advantages such as high speed, multi-cylinder configurations, variable capacity, high thermal efficiency, and suitability for diverse operating conditions. However, they also have several drawbacks: a complex structure, numerous wear parts, short maintenance intervals, sensitivity to liquid slugging, pulsating vibrations, and poor operational stability.
• A screw compressor is a new type of compression device; compared with reciprocating compressors:
Advantages:
① The machine features a compact structure, small footprint, and light weight.
② It boasts high thermal efficiency, requires fewer machining operations, and its compressor comprises only one-tenth the number of parts found in a reciprocating‑type unit. The machine has fewer wear parts, operates safely and reliably, and is easy to operate and maintain.
③ The gas flow is pulsation-free, ensuring smooth operation; the unit has low foundation requirements and does not necessitate a dedicated foundation. ④ During operation, oil is injected into the rotor chamber, resulting in low exhaust temperatures.
⑤ It is insensitive to wet‑stroke conditions; even if wet steam or a small amount of liquid enters the compressor, there is no risk of liquid hammer.
⑥ It can operate at a higher pressure ratio.
⑦ The effective compression stroke can be adjusted via a slide valve, enabling stepless cooling capacity modulation from 10% to 100%.
Disadvantages:
It requires sophisticated oil‑treatment equipment, including high‑efficiency oil separators and oil coolers, and generates significant noise—typically exceeding 85 dB—necessitating sound‑proofing measures.
Compared with reciprocating compressors, centrifugal compressors offer higher rotational speeds, greater air delivery rates, reduced mechanical wear, fewer wear parts, simpler maintenance, longer continuous operating life, lower vibration, and smoother operation. They also place modest demands on the foundation. At high flow rates, they feature a light unit weight, compact dimensions, and a small footprint. Their capacity can be continuously adjusted over a range of 30% to 100%, and they lend themselves readily to multi-stage compression and throttling, meeting the requirements of certain chemical processes. They are easy to automate, and for large units, they can be directly driven by cost‑effective industrial steam turbines, which provides an economic advantage for plants with waste‑heat steam. However, their drawbacks include relatively high noise frequencies, substantial cooling‑water consumption, and the potential for surge under improper operating conditions.
• Comparison of the performance characteristics of three common types of compression refrigeration machines (reciprocating, screw, and centrifugal)
In refrigeration systems, due to the differences in their operating principles, reciprocating and screw compressors exhibit distinct factors influencing pressure loss and leakage losses.
For reciprocating refrigeration compressors, the primary factors influencing pressure loss and leakage loss are the quality of the valves and their sealing performance when closed. This is because, during intake, the suction valve must overcome spring resistance (from the compression spring), and as gas flows through the valve, the relatively small flow cross-section results in higher flow velocities, generating additional flow resistance. Consequently, throughout the suction process, the pressure inside the cylinder remains lower than that in the suction line; similarly, during the discharge process, the cylinder pressure exceeds that in the discharge line. If the valve passage has a smaller cross-sectional area, the resistance loss increases. Likewise, if the valve disc is heavier or the valve spring force is greater, resistance losses also rise, thereby reducing the pressure coefficient.
For screw-type refrigeration compressors, the primary factors influencing pressure loss and leakage loss are the gas flow velocity.
In screw-type refrigeration compressors, the performance of the screw rotor is critical. If the screw’s tooth profile is a symmetrical circular‑arc shape, it is relatively easy to manufacture. By contrast, an asymmetrical tooth profile yields a larger volumetric displacement and higher efficiency. Reducing the length‑to‑diameter ratio of the screw enhances its structural strength, improves the operational reliability of the compressor, and facilitates further development toward higher pressure ratios.
In screw-type refrigeration compressors, among two pairs of screws with identical diameter and length, the pair with the higher rotor‑area utilization coefficient exhibits a greater displacement. On the surface, a larger rotor‑area utilization coefficient appears to enhance the compressor’s performance. However, if this coefficient becomes excessively high, it can compromise the screw’s strength and stiffness.
In screw-type refrigeration compressors, reducing the number of threads on the screws can increase the inter‑tooth cross‑sectional area, thereby boosting the compressor’s displacement. On the surface, fewer threads appear to be beneficial for compressor performance. However, if the number of threads is too low, it will compromise the screw’s flexural strength and stiffness.
In screw-type refrigeration compressors, increasing the peripheral speed of the screws allows for reductions in both the external dimensions and the mass of the compressor, while also decreasing the relative leakage through the clearances. This, in turn, enhances the volumetric efficiency and thermal efficiency of the compressor. On the surface, a higher peripheral speed appears to improve compressor performance. However, if the peripheral speed becomes excessively high, it will correspondingly increase flow losses associated with gas motion at the suction and discharge ports as well as within the inter‑tooth clearance.
Among the three common types of refrigeration compressors—reciprocating, screw, and centrifugal—the inertia generated by the reciprocating motion is the primary drawback of reciprocating compressors. Due to the frequent impact of this inertial force, the valve system and the crank‑connecting‑rod mechanism in reciprocating compressors are particularly susceptible to wear and damage.
Among the three common types of refrigeration compressors—reciprocating, screw, and centrifugal—the significant noise generated during operation is the primary drawback of screw compressors. Due to the effects of periodic high‑velocity flow of refrigerant gas through the suction and discharge ports, as well as leakage through clearances, it is essential to select an appropriate screw rotational speed for screw compressors.
Among the three common types of refrigeration compressors—reciprocating, screw, and centrifugal— Surge is the primary drawback of centrifugal refrigeration compressors. 。
The cause of surge in centrifugal refrigeration compressors is that, when the cooling water flow to the condenser decreases to a certain threshold, the compressor’s flow rate drops significantly, leading to severe gas backflow within its flow passages and a sudden drop in discharge pressure. Although the centrifugal compressor and the condenser operate in tandem, the pressure of the refrigerant vapor in the condenser does not decrease instantaneously. Consequently, the condenser pressure can exceed the compressor’s discharge pressure, causing refrigerant vapor to flow backward into the compressor until the condenser pressure falls to match the compressor’s discharge pressure.
At this point, the centrifugal refrigeration compressor resumes delivering refrigerant vapor to the condenser, increasing the flow rate and returning to normal operation. However, once the refrigerant pressure in the condenser recovers to its original level, the compressor’s flow rate decreases again, the discharge pressure begins to drop, and backflow occurs. This cycle repeats continuously, giving rise to periodic oscillations in the refrigerant flow. Therefore, in centrifugal refrigeration compressors, the cooling water flow to the condenser should not be too low; otherwise, the compressor may experience severe vibrations during operation, which, in extreme cases, could lead to catastrophic failure.