News
Overview of the Development of Underground Gas Storage Facilities Worldwide (Reprinted from Resource Network)
Source: Resource Network Author: Li Hua Published on: November 21, 2008
Natural gas storage and transportation engineering is one of the key links and essential infrastructure components of the entire natural gas industry. At present, global demand for natural gas continues to grow, and its share in primary energy consumption is steadily increasing. Constrained by their own resource endowments, many countries are becoming increasingly reliant on imported natural gas. To ensure energy security, numerous nations have adopted proactive measures to address the challenges of gas storage and supply‑demand balancing. Constructing underground gas storage facilities represents a relatively advanced approach to mitigating seasonal imbalances between natural gas supply and demand, and it has now become a critical component of the natural gas supply chain. The current status of the development and construction of underground gas storage facilities worldwide is as follows:
In 2000, the total working gas volume worldwide reached 3100 × 10^8 m³, with a daily peak‑shaving capacity of 44.6 × 10^8 m³. In Western Europe, approximately 78 underground storage facilities were in operation, with a working gas volume of about 550 × 10^8 m³ and a daily peak‑shaving capacity of 10.9 × 10^8 m³. In Eastern Europe and Central Asia, roughly 67 underground storage facilities were operational, boasting a working gas volume of around 1310 × 10^8 m³ and a daily peak‑shaving capacity of 10 × 10^8 m³. Driven by fluctuations in the natural gas market, global underground gas storage capacity has grown rapidly in recent years; by 2004, the total number of such facilities worldwide had risen to 610. Underground gas storage technology has garnered significant attention worldwide, and related technologies have advanced swiftly. China’s underground gas storage program is still in its early stages; to date, six depleted oil and gas reservoirs have been repurposed for this purpose. Nevertheless, compared with international standards, China’s underground gas storage technology still lags behind. Currently, overseas research and development efforts are focused on several emerging technologies.
I. Development of Four-Dimensional Seismic Exploration Techniques Suitable for Reservoir-Forming Geological Units
Identifying geological formations suitable for underground gas storage differs from exploring an oil or gas reservoir; the former is considerably more complex. A reservoir with an appropriate caprock does not necessarily lend itself to natural gas storage. To ensure safe and secure storage, the geological structure must prevent any leakage of the stored gas, requiring both continuous caprock integrity and structural sealability. Modern high-resolution seismic exploration techniques can resolve subtle structural features, including gas–liquid interfaces and lateral variations in stratigraphic lithology. Four-dimensional seismic technology, currently under development, holds significant promise for identifying structures well-suited for use as underground gas storage facilities. This approach relies on a suite of advanced methods, such as seismic sensors deployed at uniform intervals on the surface or permanently installed in wells, as well as multi‑layer seismic techniques—including AVO (Amplitude Versus Offset)—that enable more precise characterization of reservoir rock properties. Advancing seismic imaging capabilities can reduce initial uncertainties in the early stages of underground gas storage development, minimize the number of observation wells, and facilitate optimal placement of storage wells within favorable structural settings, thereby further reducing overall well counts.
II. Subgrade Support Design Technology
In the capital investment for constructing an underground gas storage facility, the cost of the cushion gas accounts for the largest share, typically 30% to 40% of the total investment. If a substitute gas could be used in place of natural gas as the cushion gas, this portion of the investment would be significantly reduced. Abroad, experiments have been conducted using inert gases or gas mixtures as cushion gases; currently, gas mixtures are more widely employed, and seven storage facilities have already undergone such trials. Deploying gas mixtures as cushion gas requires specialized technologies, modeling approaches, and measurement tools to accurately account for gas–gas miscibility phenomena. Test results indicate that, with the use of cushion gas, investment costs can be cut by approximately 20%.
III. Large-Diameter Well and Horizontal Well Technologies
In underground gas storage facilities, completing wells with large-diameter wellbores can significantly increase the volume of natural gas available for peak‑shaving. When no liquids—such as oil, water, or condensate—are produced, adopting large‑diameter completions has become a standard design practice worldwide. Furthermore, to minimize pressure losses along the production string, most wells are designed with a single casing diameter, minimizing reductions in diameter and thereby preventing gas turbulence. In underground gas storage, the primary objective of drilling horizontal wells is also to enhance the peak‑shaving capacity of individual wells. For reservoirs with low permeability, horizontal wells are more suitable than vertical wells. For a given reservoir, the peak‑shaving capacity of a horizontal well can be 1.5 to 6 times that of a vertical well, depending largely on reservoir characteristics and the length of the horizontal section. During operation, horizontal wells can also help mitigate water coning. If the horizontal section intersects the gas–water contact, constructing the storage within a water‑bearing formation of extremely low permeability during production makes such techniques indispensable. These large‑diameter, horizontal‑well technologies are likewise applicable when converting low‑permeability, depleted oil reservoirs into underground gas storage facilities.
IV. Salt-Cavern Gas Storage Technology
Both reservoir-type gas storage facilities and aquifer‑based gas storage facilities store natural gas in naturally occurring rock pores, whereas salt cavern gas storage differs in that it stores gas within cavities created by artificial dissolution of salt. The primary approaches to reducing the construction costs of salt cavern gas storage are: employing modern dissolution technologies to increase cavern volume; and lowering the minimum operating pressure while raising the maximum operating pressure. Salt caverns began to be used for gas storage in the 1960s. The first U.S. salt cavern gas storage facility was built in Marysville, Michigan, in 1961; Canada’s first such facility opened in Melville, Saskatchewan, in 1964; Armenia’s first was constructed in Abovian in 1964; France’s inaugural facility was commissioned at Tersanne in 1968; and Germany’s first was established in Kiel in 1969. In the early stages of development, these caverns were relatively small, with capacities ranging from (3–10) × 10⁸ m³/day. With advances in engineering technology, by the end of the 20th century, the total capacity of European salt cavern gas storage had reached (400–600) × 10¹² m³/day. Cavern capacity is primarily constrained by pressure losses in injection and production wells and by safety requirements during equipment operation. Reducing the minimum operating pressure can increase the effective working gas volume and lower investment in cushion gas. For every 1 MPa reduction in minimum operating pressure, approximately 10%–15% of total capital expenditure can be saved. The maximum storage capacity of a single cavern is closely tied to its maximum operating pressure; increasing the maximum operating pressure by 10% typically boosts the effective working gas volume by about 15%. However, the maximum operating pressure is limited by the gas‑tightness of the underlying salt layer. Generally, the maximum operating pressure should remain below the overburden pressure exerted by the overlying strata, which averages around 0.23 MPa/m; in certain special zones, this gradient may be less than 0.2 MPa/m.
The cost of salt‑dissolution cavern construction accounts for approximately 25% to 35% of the total investment and requires a lengthy process. Dissolving each cubic meter of salt consumes 7 to 9 cubic meters of water, producing brine with a concentration of about 300 kg/m³. This brine is typically used industrially to produce sodium chloride, reinjected underground, or even discharged into the sea. Salt‑dissolution caverns necessitate two well strings: one for injecting water and the other for returning the brine. Concurrently, various monitoring and testing procedures are carried out to ensure that the resulting cavity conforms to the design specifications. The depth of the well strings must be adjusted incrementally based on the dissolution progress; however, a protective barrier—formed using liquefied petroleum gas, crude oil, nitrogen, or even natural gas—must be established at the top to prevent dissolution of the overlying roof strata. Currently, many countries worldwide are engaged in research on advanced salt‑dissolution technologies, such as SMRI and INVDIR’s SALTXX, as well as Gaz de France’s SURMOVINER. It is reported that these new developments can reduce both the number of operational steps and the frequency of sonic logging by at least 50%, while cutting capital expenditures by more than 10%. During the dissolution process, pressurized injection of gases—including natural gas, inert gases, diesel fuel, or liquefied petroleum gas—can help safeguard the roof. Once the cavern has been fully dissolved, it requires re‑completion to facilitate brine removal and the initial gas injection. Natural gas is injected through the annular space between the brine‑disposal string and the production tubing (or casing), while the brine is produced via the brine‑disposal string. The overall time required for cavern construction depends on the size of the salt dome (or salt structure): some projects take just over a year, while others may extend to several years. Simultaneous salt dissolution and gas storage represents an innovative approach to cavern development, which has already been successfully implemented at the Moss Salt Mine in Texas and the Egan Salt Mine in Louisiana, yielding significant reductions in capital costs.
The initial phase of this type of salt cavern is still created using the conventional water‑soluble salt method. First, the upper salt layer is dissolved to the designed dimensions, while the lower layer remains undissolved at this stage. This technique requires specialized equipment, such as a wellhead and a dissolution tubing string, which ensures that the upper cavity can store gas while allowing the lower section to continue dissolving and forming the cavern smoothly. As the upper cavern discharges brine and stores gas, the lower salt layer begins to dissolve and develop the cavern. The gas stored in the upper portion serves as a protective caprock during the dissolution of the lower layer. Throughout the dissolution process, the interface between the gas and the brine is tightly controlled, remaining essentially centered within the cavern. Once the lower salt layer has dissolved to a diameter comparable to that of the upper cavern, the same well completion and wellhead configuration is employed to optimize reservoir operation and expand storage capacity. At this point, the gas–brine interface no longer stays fixed but oscillates vertically. Under these conditions, even stricter control of the gas–brine interface becomes essential to safeguard the caprock and prevent natural gas leakage. Salt cavern gas storage facilities are typically constructed within salt layers approximately 150–400 meters thick. Thinner salt layers, ranging from 60 to 100 meters in thickness, can also be used for underground gas storage, though their storage capacity is smaller, typically between (5–10) × 10⁴ m³/day. However, in certain areas—primarily along the margins of sedimentary basins—the salt layers are less than 60 meters thick, making it clearly impractical to build conventional underground gas storage facilities in such formations. The primary challenge lies in controlling the dissolution pathways. Thin salt layers invariably contain non‑dissolving interlayers; unlike large‑scale caverns, gravity cannot effectively separate the phases in these thinner formations. Based on geomechanical analyses and three‑dimensional modeling of cavern flow paths across cross‑sections of 1,000–3,000 m², constructing an underground gas storage facility with a horizontal section several hundred meters long and a capacity of (10–100) × 10⁴ m³ appears appropriate for such thin salt layers. Although the capital investment for this type of facility is 15%–20% higher than that of conventional salt caverns, the technology is gradually gaining widespread adoption in Europe and North America. Russia is also planning to implement this approach.
V. Technology for Constructing Reservoirs in Linear Bedrock Caves
Linear rock‑formation cavern storage technology offers an alternative for countries lacking suitable geological formations to construct underground gas storage facilities. The core principle of this approach is to store gas at high pressure (15–25 MPa) within relatively shallow (100–200 m) linear rock cavities. Pressure is transmitted via pipelines embedded in cemented layers, while the surrounding rock serves to withstand the high pressures. A key limitation of this type of storage lies in the lithological characteristics of the host formation. In Grangesberg, Sweden, this technology was successfully applied to create a 130 m³ cavity at a depth of 50 m. In 1997, a demonstration storage facility with a capacity of 40,000 m³ was constructed at Skallen in southern Sweden. Pilot tests and associated evaluations were completed in 2003. The construction cost of such a facility is approximately two to four times that of conventional underground storage, yet its maintenance and operating costs are significantly lower than those of liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) storage systems. Due to the large throughput, LPG storage units can be cycled several times per year; under comparable conditions, their service costs are comparable to the operating expenses of other gas‑storage technologies.
VI. Optimized Operation Technologies for Gas Storage Facilities
Currently, numerous emerging technologies are being employed to help operators manage underground gas storage facilities more effectively. Key advances include gravel‑packing sand control for unconsolidated porous reservoirs; polymer‑based profile‑control and water‑cut reduction techniques; consolidation methods for unconsolidated porous reservoirs; advanced mathematical models and software—such as 3D simulation tools that characterize reservoir geometry and rock properties; equipment maintenance and operational technologies for underground gas storage; new logging tools, including nuclear magnetic resonance, enhanced 3D seismic sensors, and multi‑fluid and sand‑particle detectors; as well as permanent sensors and/or downhole fiber‑optic systems capable of continuously monitoring reservoir parameters, particularly in salt caverns. In addition to technological improvements and the development of novel technologies, storage facility owners and operators are also addressing optimization challenges on both technical and economic fronts. Current areas of focus include: first, more sophisticated analytical tools, such as risk management and stochastic modeling; second, integrating storage‑facility models into simplified gas‑network representations; third, routine management and control of individual pieces of equipment; and fourth, leveraging real‑world economic data—such as marginal costs, operating expenses, variations in storage capacity and gas production for each unit, and the cost of maintaining supply levels through imports.